Thursday, October 29, 2026

Make it Stick: A Book Critique

In the book Make it Stick by Brown, Roediger, and McDaniel, they provide a variety of research backed techniques that improve the ability of individuals to retain the information they are taught. The book also emphasizes that the ability to learn is not fixed at our birth or at any point in our lives we all can continually learn if we so desire. 

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and could easily see how to implement the various techniques described. The authors did a great job of giving examples of different types of individuals successfully using the highlighted techniques such as retrieval practice, mixed practice, making connection to previous knowledge, embracing struggle, and avoiding delusion of knowledge.

While the authors did a great job of describing these techniques, did they use them in the writing of this text to help us retain the information. I would say that the did well in achieving the retrieval practice. Particularly when you get to the final chapter, the authors us ask for you to recall the details in each of the chapters to bring it together with the examples.  Additionally, the I believe the authors did a good job of using the concept of struggle. Many chapters began with stories where your brain was not quite sure how it fit in with the title of the chapter. While your brain is working to construct meaning with the chapter title and the story, it helps with solidifying the learning once it is explained.

The authors missed a bit on the varied practice concept. This would be a bit more challenging in a book, however the chapters are themed and, in an order, so as a reader you are not working between concepts in a single chapter. The authors do mention previous techniques in some chapters; however, I do not believe this is true mixed or interleaved practice. The final chapter, which is more of a summary, would be the only place I would say that mixed practice is possibly the closest. 

I would give this book a 10/10 and highly recommend that everyone read it. There is benefit in it from students, to teachers, to employers, to parents and beyond. I have changed my thinking and some of my practices as a result.

Works Cited
Brown, P. C., Roediger III, H. L., & McDaniel, M. A. (2014). Make It Stick. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

 

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Blogging – it’s hard! Content – Audience – Presentation – Oh My!


When blogging to inform about a particular topic you have studied and learned in some detail, this struggle is extremely valuable to the blogger. What is the benefit to the blogger? The blogger is trying to take the information they know and then answer a question for their audience. This process is identified in the book Make It Stick  (Brown, Roediger III, & McDaniel, 2014). as generation and benefits the blogger because creating the answer “strengthen(s) the route to the gap in … learning … and connections are made to the related material” (Brown et al., 2014, pg.88). Additionally, the struggle to generate the blogging material also benefits because the blogger is practicing bringing up the information another concept in Make It Stick called retrieval practice. For this concept, the blogger benefits because “effortful retrieval makes for stronger learning and retention” (Brown et al., 2014, pg.43). While recalling and generating the information, the blogger is making the knowledge stick and easier to share and to continue to connect with other knowledge. This struggle illustrates the concept of desirable difficulties described in Make It Stick. Although generating ideas, retrieving information, and organizing a blog post may make the writing process more challenging, these difficulties can improve learning and long-term retention when they require meaningful mental effort.

Beyond these components of knowledge growth through the struggle surrounding content, there is an additional struggle in that likely the blogger was not taught to blog. This is called generative learning; “trying to solve a problem without the benefit of having been taught” (Brown et al., 2014, pg.94). In Make It Stick, the authors discuss an individual who wants to be a gardener, however, has no knowledge of the topic. Through many struggles of learning about plants, gardening, classifications, and experimentation, the individual was soon an expert answering questions from experience farmers and sharing tips and tricks with a wide variety of individuals growing gardening enthusiasts. All of this would not have happened if the individual has not been willing to struggle and experience some discomfort. Accepting both led to success and joy.

Today with AI, you could create a bot that simply writes the posts for you and puts them up. Just create a thoughtful query and set AI to work. However, this approach has no benefit to the blogger and additionally I believe would result in a potential loss of knowledge of which you are purporting to be an expert. Even though it may be challenging to create the content, that creation sharpens your knowledge through the benefit of recall and generation as mentioned above. Beyond simply bringing the information into a position in the brain for easy access, creation often also requires bringing concepts together and making new connections. These connections strength both the active concept and the one with which the connection is made. All this work, then makes the struggle of blogging less intense for that topic. With the need to change topics to continue to inform, more information brings connections in the brain, and the blogger becomes more of an expert. 

Beyond missing out on knowledge gains when AI creates the blog post, you may be losing your audience as the AI bot may not be good at engaging and taking feedback from readers and this feedback is important in the iterative process which provides further knowledge growth this time in a new topic – how to write engaging content. Reading through reviews and concepts requires the blogger to process the information and then act; again, increasing growth through struggle.  From the perspective of Make It Stick, the important distinction is whether the learner is doing the cognitive work necessary to retrieve, generate, and connect ideas. AI should support that effort rather than replace it.

Works Cited

Brown, P. C., Roediger III, H. L., & McDaniel, M. A. (2014). Make It Stick. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

 

Image source: https://writersrumpus.com/2022/04/15/5-books-to-help-you-beat-writers-block/

Sunday, October 18, 2026

It’s Hard and That’s Good

 


When in school, we often get excited about that lesson that was so easy we picked it up right away with very little to no effort. However, this sort of learning does not provide the learner with knowledge that sticks. When a bit more effort, not even a lot, just some is added to learning the ability to retain and reshare the information is increased.

In the book Make it Stick by Brown, Roediger, and McDaniel, they provide the example of having student remember sets of word pairs. Those students who were given the pairs with a few letters missing requiring their brain to complete the word were more successful at remembering the pairs. For example, if the pair was foot – shoe, the student would see f_ _t, s_ _e. (Brown, Roediger III, & McDaniel, 2014). This little bit of extra effort resulted in statistical improvement in the ability to recall the word pairs.

However, it is important to note that this effort must be within reason. If students are pushed too far or if they have no reference to previous knowledge to link the new knowledge, then the struggle is not beneficial and does not provide an increase in the ability to recall and retain the information. 

As an educator, it is important that students understand that struggle is good and an important part of learning. Beyond struggle, failure is even better. In the classroom, there is too much focus on not failing that the full potential of students is not only stifled but, for those who are continuously successful, can even be curtailed their entire life and their true potential never fulfilled. Allowing students to struggle and fail results in far more memorable learning than having everyone ace very exam given. Yet if as an educator you put this forward, you will be met with much resistance by parents and administration alike as the common misnomer is that students need to always be and feel successful. Somehow educators must bring into common knowledge the many research studies completed that show the contrary; struggle means more learning. 

Make it Stick: A Book Critique

In the book   Make it Stick   by Brown, Roediger, and McDaniel, they provide a variety of research backed techniques that improve the abilit...